Summary
TODO: Summary
Review questions
Content
Initial explanation of why salvation is about faith, not knowledge
Ichthys: Initial explanation of why salvation is about faith, not knowledge
The following contains discussion of content that was not originally made by me. Please help the original content rank higher in the algorithms by viewing it at its original location, and also giving it a like and a comment and so on (if applicable):
Also, be sure to follow/subscribe to/support the original content creator on all their platforms:
- Website: Ichthys.com
The things labeled "summary points" on this page are highly derivative of the original content, since they are summarizing the original content.
Overview
Source clip from Ichthys
Response #1:
Good to hear from you, my friend. Although I’m sorry to hear that you are still troubled and wrestling: Jacob wrestled too and was lamed for it – then he kept wrestling and was blessed for it. Like him, we should resist wrestling against the truth (as he first did) then hold on tight to the Lord ever after (as he did; see the link).
In a nutshell, salvation is not about knowledge – it is about faith. Salvation is all about trusting God, believing in Him and His truth. How much truth do we need to be saved in the first place? Only as much as a mustard seed’s worth (Matt.13:31-32; 17:20). What if we didn’t understand everything about salvation when we were saved? We were saved anyway. And no one understands everything about salvation when they are saved. That is impossible. In the Basics series, BB 4A: Christology is 220 pages single-spaced; BB 4B: Soteriology is 143 pages single-spaced. They both contain many verse citations as well. And it’s not as if the rest of the Basics Series is not in many ways applicable to salvation-knowledge (the Trinity is discussed in BB 1, for example, the baptism of the Spirit in BB 5). I certainly didn’t know or understand most of the information in these studies when I was saved at circa five years old. But I DO remember trusting God to deliver me from death.
If a person affirmatively denies certain basic truths such as the deity of Christ, that is an obstacle to salvation (we see that plainly enough in the Bible; e.g., Jn.1:11). But if a person doesn’t yet know or understand everything, that is not an obstacle to salvation. Salvation is about faith, not knowledge. The Holy Spirit, we must remember, is the Evangelist in chief. He is the One who makes the truth real to unbelievers who hear the gospel. He is God and can easily discern genuine faith from mere academic interest. He is clearly able to provide whatever is necessary to be saved to anyone who wants to be saved, anyone who is willing to believe – and it’s all about that faith. Faith is often called in this ministry “free-will faith”, because faith is the capacity that God has given us to respond to Him, to choose for Him. This is easy to do (for us, since Christ paid for it). Yet many refuse to do so. Why? Because faith is a response of obedience and trust, using our image of God to respond to God Himself, putting our hope and trust in Him to deliver us seeing as how we can’t deliver ourselves from death.
Arguing about the mechanics where the Bible doesn’t delineate them is not profitable. What we can say for sure is that some are saved and some are not. What is the distinction? Believers believe, unbelievers do not believe (Jn.3:18). That means that believers have responded to God, to His truth, to His Spirit; believers have accepted things that cannot be proven empirically by trusting in God instead (Heb.11:1). And believers are saved as a result. How do we know we are saved? We know from the Spirit whom God has placed in us when we became one with His Son Jesus Christ.
15 For you have not received a spirit of slavery [leading you] back to [a state of] fear [of damnation], but you have the Spirit who has entered you into God’s family, in whom we cry, “Abba! My Father!” 16 For the Spirit Himself testifies to our spirit that we are God’s children.
And since you are sons, God sent the Spirit of His Son into your hearts, crying, “Abba, Father!”
If we are saved – and we are, as the Spirit tells us – then what is the point of trying to peel the onion back to discover just how much we knew when we were first saved? Not only is this pointless in my opinion but it is also impossible (since we really don’t know with complete specificity what we thought or believed yesterday, not with certainty, and certainly not many years ago) . . . and also dangerous: because such exercises of looking backwards of necessity hinder our forward progress. And the Christian life is all about moving forward, concentrating on making spiritual progress TODAY; not fretting about what mistakes we might have made yesterday.
12 [It is] not that I have already gotten [what I am striving for], nor that I have already completed [my course]. Rather, I am continuing to pursue [the prize] in hopes of fully acquiring it – [this prize for whose acquisition] I was myself acquired by Christ Jesus. 13 Brethren, I do not consider that I have already acquired it. This one thing only [do I keep in mind]. Forgetting what lies behind me [on the course] and straining towards the [course] ahead, 14 I continue to drive straight for the tape, towards the prize to which God has called us from the beginning [of our race] in Christ Jesus. 15 So as many as are [spiritually] mature, let us have this attitude (i.e., of focusing on our spiritual advance and reward and not getting hung up on what lies behind: vv.13-14), and if in any matter your attitude is off-center, God will reveal that to you (i.e., assuming you are mature and are advancing as you should). 16 But with respect to the progress you have made, keep on advancing in the same way!
I studied theology formally in seminary and also engaged in a survey of formal theology in preparation for writing the Basics series. I can tell you that there is very little profit in that either. The problem with traditional theology is the same as the problem with developing logical constructs and then attempting to apply them to the Bible. The Bible contains its own system of truth. Theology and logic (often working hand in hand) prescribe systematic categories, many of which do not even occur in actual scripture, and them attempt to jam the Bible into them. A theologian or logician comes up with a concept or a category and then interprets the Bible accordingly. How many angels can dance of the head of a pin? Approaching that as a theological problem, I can see scriptures which might be applied. Approaching it as a logical problem, I can think of arguments which might be deployed. But the fallacy of the approach is to be seen in the truth that this is the wrong question to be asking in the first place. Not only does the Bible not ask it or imply that it needs to be asked, but no serious Christian who wants to live for Jesus Christ would ever think to ask it. This example may be obvious, but it turns out that much of what traditional theology asks is similarly wrong-headed – because its questions come from the logical development of theological systems which are in fact extra-biblically derived. Do you want to know what a “dispensation” is? Then look to see what the Bible actually has to say about the issue; don’t develop a theory / system and seek to plug into it all manner of things where it does not actually fit.
The above is a long way of saying that I think you would have been a lot better off just reading Ichthys, putting the “bones” aside when you bumped into them (asking me about them if you had questions), but seeking to grow positively through the truth by embracing spiritual growth on every front, not tackling individual questions and issues from the past exclusively, logically, theologically.
Your Q1: Re: what is actually minimally required for salvation?
A1: Believing in God’s provision for salvation, our Savior Jesus Christ, is all that is required to be saved.
“Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved.”
Your Q2 - Re: not knowing about everything about the deity and humanity of Christ at salvation.
A2: The Spirit gave you sufficient knowledge to be saved and you were saved – and that is all that matters.
Nevertheless, God’s solid foundation stands firm, sealed with this inscription: “The Lord knows those who are his"
Your Q3a - Re: recognizing Christ’s deity later on reading scripture.
A3a: This is the way it works for all believers; that is to say, we start with a little but then we are given more – at least for all those who are willing to grow. And for all who are willing to grow, there will be tests; the fact of tests does not in any way undermine the veracity of the truth. But the devil is always trying to detach believers from the truth. And he knows our weaknesses – like a penchant for needing things neat and tidy and logical – and he is very good at using others, misguided believers or Christians in name only, to attack our faith in the truth.
…in order that Satan might not outwit us. For we are not unaware of his schemes.
Your Q3b - Re: ‘problem’ of not knowing of Christ’s eternity at salvation.
A3b: I don’t think we have a problem at all. God is God. If we have questions – about anything in scripture – there may be answers in the Bible or these may be available through ministries that teach (like Ichthys). But our questions do not overrule the truth nor can they be allowed to wrongly categorize the truth; false categorization is the original sin of all traditional theology. Believers who are not pastor-teachers by gifting (and also those who are but who are not prepared sufficiently to do their own research) need to read their Bibles, yes, but then also attend to a good teaching ministry, and wait patiently for answers rather than allowing questions to undermine their faith. Eventually, all our questions are answered – all the legitimate ones, that is, while the others fall by the wayside . . . IF we are advancing spiritually as we should be doing.
1 The Word [Jesus Christ] existed at the very beginning, and there was reciprocity between the Word and God [the Father]. 2 This One both existed and enjoyed reciprocity with God from the very beginning. 3 Everything came into being through Him, and without Him, nothing has come into being which has in fact come into being.
15 He (i.e., Jesus Christ; cf. v.13) is the exact image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation. 16 Everything in the heavens and on the earth was created by Him, things invisible as well as those visible – whether thrones, authorities, rulers or powers, everything was created through Him and for Him. 17 And He Himself is before everything, and everything subsists in Him (cf. Heb.1:3).
[Jesus Christ] is the shining forth of [the Father’s] glory, the precise image of His essence, the One who [in His deity] sustains the universe by His mighty Word.
Your Q4a - Re: having more knowledge now but still wrestling with the truth.
A4a: As a believer, you are not required to parse every verse in the Bible. That is the job of a pastor-teacher. If you feel you have this gift, wrestling with scripture and with principles you’ve been taught is part of the process, but deconstructing one’s faith-system is a dangerous business if it goes too far and too soon, even for those so gifted who are embarked on a serious course of preparation. I really feel it would be good to read the Basics series (link) and to try and accept the truth of what’s in there, putting aside the bones until things start to fall into place – which I am confident they will if you have a little faith. dio kai in the Greek doesn’t support the weight of meaning you are placing on it in Luke 1:35. This verse says that Jesus in His humanity will be called the Son of God; it doesn’t say that He is not / was not the Son of God from all eternity – which indeed He was. There is no direct contradiction here. Jesus came into the world; He couldn’t come into the world if He didn’t exist as God before He came into the world.
“For I have come down from heaven, not to do My own will, but the will of Him who sent Me."
Your Q4b - Re: others considering such wrestling as heresy.
A4b: Considered heresy by whom? The church-visible over the centuries and much more so today has been and now is largely composed of unbelievers. To the extent that those in the church-visible actually are believers, the vast majority of them are lukewarm, immature, and only marginal at best. If individuals in, e.g., the RC church were believers, why would they stay in that group? If individuals in, e.g., traditional, Calvinist, Baptist, charismatic, mega-churches, e.g., were interested in growing spiritually, why would they stay in those groups? Believe the Bible. Believe the Spirit. Believe the truth. Find a good ministry that is teaching the truth and stick with it – that is the way to grow.
- You are saved since you believe in Jesus Christ. If you want to know more about the mechanics, please read BB 4B (at the link).
- Re: worrying about all this: Don’t worry in the first place (e.g., Matt.6:25-34)! The Christian life is about joy and peace – spiritual growth, progress and progression. It is about looking forward, not looking backward. Determine to move on. We all have “tics” which, if allowed to gain our attention, will do us no good in trying to solve because they are insoluble on their own terms; but all such concerns can always be dealt with, allayed, quieted through growth and application of the truth.
“Peace I leave with you, My peace I give to you; not as the world gives do I give to you. Let not your heart be troubled, neither let it be afraid."
To reiterate, serious spiritual growth never happens through tackling “problems of concern” through fixating on them and applying logic and traditional theology. Spiritual growth requires embracing all of God’s truth in scripture through a broad-based approach by attending to a good, Bible teaching ministry, hearing, learning, believing and applying the truth. Ichthys is at your service, my friend.
I do keep you in my prayers daily.
In Jesus,
Bob L.
Summary points
Asking the right questions
With regards to the specific subpoints in this email response (Q1 through Q4b), Dr. Luginbill made the point that we have to take pains to ask the right questions. At times the questions put forward by the formal fields of logic and theology may not be those that we should actually be focusing on as believers.
For example, consider what we discussed before in our own study of what is required in order to be saved with regards to some people claiming that only people who believe a certain set of logical propositions are actually saved. We argued that taking this approach to salvation is, in essence, asking the wrong questions.
Keeping this in mind, we can see that some of the correspondent’s questions overlap with what we rejected as necessary to be saved in our past study. Rather than specific bits of knowledge, the only thing that is actually required is simple faith in Christ as our savior.
So it’s not so much that we are firmly anti-logic and anti-theology in general, but that we make sure that we aren’t letting ourselves be swayed by systems and structures that have sort of sprung up external to the Bible.
The importance of spiritual growth
Consider the balance we must strike in emphasizing:
- That specific knowledge itself is not actually necessary for baby believers to understand in order to be saved, but also
- That spiritual growth (after the point of salvation) is nevertheless critically important
In his response here, Dr. Luginbill exhorts his correspondent to sort buckle down and find a teaching ministry, because that is how one grows as a Christian.
Rather than getting hung up on specific doctrinal details (or the exact mechanics involved in things), Dr. Luginbill emphasizes that spiritual growth itself is the important thing.
Again, we get truth from the Bible, not from the logical constructs that have sprung up in the formal academic disciplines of logic and theology. And that is why Dr. Luginbill so strongly emphasizes spiritual growth itself:
The above is a long way of saying that I think you would have been a lot better off just reading Ichthys, putting the “bones” aside when you bumped into them (asking me about them if you had questions), but seeking to grow positively through the truth by embracing spiritual growth on every front, not tackling individual questions and issues from the past exclusively, logically, theologically.
Part of emphasizing spiritual growth is taking pains to not get overly fixated on specific questions or problems, but to grow spiritually as a whole. By giving the Spirit more “capital” to use in your heart, you may find that specific questions and problems end up resolving themselves in practice, without you ever actually trying to directly address them.
Group discussion: How people use irrelevant issues to distract from the salvation offer; how understanding most spiritual truth is only possible after salvation
Knowledge, belief, salvation, and epignosis
Ichthys: Knowledge, belief, salvation, and epignosis
The following contains discussion of content that was not originally made by me. Please help the original content rank higher in the algorithms by viewing it at its original location, and also giving it a like and a comment and so on (if applicable):
Also, be sure to follow/subscribe to/support the original content creator on all their platforms:
- Website: Ichthys.com
The things labeled "summary points" on this page are highly derivative of the original content, since they are summarizing the original content.
Overview
Source clip from Ichthys
Response #2:
It’s my pleasure.
As to knowing you’re saved because God helps you but worrying you’ve slipped: Yes, you ARE saved; so worrying about how is not helpful; if you want to know about the mechanics, see the links previously provided. Engaging with false theologies really is a tangled web and doesn’t do anyone any good. The more complicated traditional theology has gotten, the farther away from spiritual growth it has erred – to the point that many famous theologians of the present and past centuries probably were / are not even saved. Anyone can deploy reason and logic, but learning and understanding the truth of the Word of God requires faith. The ONLY way to fully “know” any of God’s truth is to believe it. That is how the Spirit turns mere knowledge into “full-knowledge”, Greek epignosis, the only “knowledge” that builds us up and brings us closer to God (see the link).
As to knowing a tremendous amount of truth: knowing is good, but only believing benefits a believer. For teaching to be beneficial, it has to be true AND believed. I might also observe that many if not most of the other genuine ministries out there of which I am aware while they do teach some truth, tend to be very basic, not providing the sort of solid food necessary for real spiritual growth (Heb.6:1); and most places layer on a lot of pablum . . . and not a little non-truth as well. That combination makes faith difficult and serious spiritual growth nearly impossible. Not to mention that there are far more “ministries” and “churches” in the world today which are not even genuinely of God at all.
1. To reiterate, salvation is about faith, not knowledge. If a person is willing to be saved, the Holy Spirit knows that; and the Spirit will give that person enough understanding of the truth of the gospel so as to be saved. When Paul and Silas say, “believe in the Lord Jesus Christ and you will be saved!” (Acts 16:31), they don’t footnote that with a fifteen page explanation of the Trinity and the plan of salvation. I dare say, most Christians today do not really even understand what the blood of Christ, the spiritual death of our Lord for all sin, really is or means. What is needed to be saved is the will to be saved on our part by believing and the object of faith in whom we believe, our Savior Jesus Christ: God helping us when we want to be saved through Jesus Christ the One in whom we believe.
2. Once saved, a person is saved as long as said person believes in Jesus Christ. Even if it is just a matter of that mustard seed of faith being kept secure by the Spirit (1Jn.3:9). Only unbelievers are not saved (Jn.3:18). For a believer to become unsaved, i.e., apostasy, that requires the complete death of faith (see the link). Failure to grow, failure to pursue sanctification, that is to say, backsliding and sinning, often does lead to a believer reverting to the status of unbeliever. But again that is a very deliberate choice, not a matter of mere knowledge or lack thereof. It’s not about knowledge; it’s about faith. Apostasy in Greek is “rebellion”, rejecting God’s authority once accepted in the same manner of Satan and his followers. It doesn’t happen accidentally. Our Lord tells us that tribulation, persecution, and testing are the prime reasons for apostasy (Matt.13:21; Mk.4:17; Lk.8:13); if a person starts to blame God for some disaster or personal loss, turning away from Him is often the result. But confusion over doctrinal points is never the cause of apostasy. Why not? Because if a believer is genuinely seeking the truth, the truth will be provided (Matt.7:7; Lk.11:9). It may take perseverance, it may take some humility in accepting things which otherwise one might not be willing to accept for whatever reason (and here I always recommend putting aside those “bones” until other things fall into place), but the questions will be answered for all who stick with it.
3. Walter Martin wrote a book on cults. I would not consider him the ultimate authority on what is “respectable”. As to your statement, to the effect that respectable Christians being of the opinion that Jesus as the pre-incarnate Word existed in some mysterious form not fully understood, well, there are a lot of “respectable Christians” who are baby believers and who have no desire to grow spiritually. And most of the churches out there today in Laodicea are not providing much more than pablum making growth impossible. The ecumenical approach is to boil everything down to a sort of gruel which doesn’t have much nutritional value but which will not offend anyone. Better is to search for truly good and nutritious teaching which will lead to growth. By the by, I’m sure that the vast majority of “respectable Christians” and like churches would want nothing to do with myself or this ministry and would disparage it given the chance. I don’t care a fig for the opinions of the world, not of unbelievers and not of immature believers. I respect the Lord and His opinion.
Am I now trying to win the approval of human beings, or of God? Or am I trying to please people? If I were still trying to please people, I would not be a servant of Christ.
4. As to whether these beliefs are incompatible with salvation, as explained above, a person only has to be willing to accept the Father’s will in Jesus Christ to be saved. The details are provided later . . . to those who want them. A good many Christians are confused about a good many doctrinal principles. Entire denominations are built upon incorrect positions which they wear like a crown. You could spend a hundred years investigating their ins and outs and not draw an inch closer to the Lord. OR you could start reading Ichthys with some diligence and commitment, believe what you are taught, and grow in the peace and joy of Jesus Christ. A person can pick through the old vomit forever and not be helped by that (2Pet.2:22). It’s much better to drink deeply of the truth of the Word from a good font of truth. As I always say, if Ichthys is not your cup of tea, there are some other places (such as Bible Academy – and I now also recommend Bible docs [see the links]), but I have to say that I don’t think your present method is a good one. It’s left you spinning your wheels and not taken you forward. At some point, you have to find a ministry to trust and commit to, believing what you are taught. Skepticism is good in the secular realm; spiritual growth requires believing the truth.
“Make a tree good and its fruit will be good, or make a tree bad and its fruit will be bad, for a tree is recognized by its fruit.” Matthew 12:33 NIV
Find a good tree, eat and grow. It’s just that simple – or hard.
In Jesus,
Bob L.
Summary points
The difference between head knowledge and epignosis, and the dearth of correct knowledge in Laodicea to begin with
Put simply, the only sort of knowledge that does us any good as Christians is the sort that is mixed with faith/belief:
Anyone can deploy reason and logic, but learning and understanding the truth of the Word of God requires faith. The ONLY way to fully “know” any of God’s truth is to believe it. That is how the Spirit turns mere knowledge into “full-knowledge”, Greek epignosis, the only “knowledge” that builds us up and brings us closer to God (see the link).
As to knowing a tremendous amount of truth: knowing is good, but only believing benefits a believer. For teaching to be beneficial, it has to be true AND believed.
It is a very simple point, but extremely, extremely important. For there are in fact many people who can talk eloquently about very many theological subjects, yet believe very little, and so it does them little good spiritually.
And on the flip side, there are those who the world looks down upon (be it due to a lack of education or even raw intelligence) who are in fact much further along spiritually. Because they mix what knowledge they do have with faith.
Now, we may observe that it is not like knowledge has nothing to do with all this. You can’t believe something (in the sense of applying your faith to it) unless you actually comprehend it to begin with. So clearly we need to be very interested in acquiring more doctrinally accurate spiritual knowledge so that we can believe it, and in so doing, add it to our “storehouses” of truth in our hearts = the capital by which the indwelling Holy Spirit can work in us.
There is in this a sort of person who falls into a slightly different trap than the “ever learning but never believing” crowd, and that is those who don’t even pursue much spiritual knowledge to begin with. Unfortunately, this is the precise state of many lukewarm believers in our age of Laodicea:
I might also observe that many if not most of the other genuine ministries out there of which I am aware while they do teach some truth, tend to be very basic, not providing the sort of solid food necessary for real spiritual growth (Heb.6:1)
It can actually get even worse too. What if instead of not taking in much truth (which at least has the advantage of not causing active harm), people actually actively seek wrong things, and then believe these wrong things?
[A]nd most places [that actually teach much of anything] layer on a lot of pablum . . . and not a little non-truth as well. […] Not to mention that there are far more “ministries” and “churches” in the world today which are not even genuinely of God at all.
Here again, this is no good.
So in all this we can see that there are many “permutations” that do not benefit spiritual growth:
- Seeking but not believing
- Not seeking much to begin with
- Actively seeking wrong things and then believing them
However, there is only one proper path: seeking doctrinally accurate truth, and then actually believing it.
This being the case, we should not focus on disproving or otherwise concerning ourselves with that which is false, but instead only focus on positively believing that which is actually true:
A good many Christians are confused about a good many doctrinal principles. Entire denominations are built upon incorrect positions which they wear like a crown. You could spend a hundred years investigating their ins and outs and not draw an inch closer to the Lord. OR you could start reading Ichthys with some diligence and commitment, believe what you are taught, and grow in the peace and joy of Jesus Christ. A person can pick through the old vomit forever and not be helped by that (2Pet.2:22). It’s much better to drink deeply of the truth of the Word from a good font of truth. As I always say, if Ichthys is not your cup of tea, there are some other places (such as Bible Academy – and I now also recommend Bible docs [see the links]), but I have to say that I don’t think your present method is a good one. It’s left you spinning your wheels and not taken you forward. At some point, you have to find a ministry to trust and commit to, believing what you are taught. Skepticism is good in the secular realm; spiritual growth requires believing the truth.
Again emphasizing that it is faith not knowledge that saves us
I love this way Dr. Luginbill puts it here:
When Paul and Silas say, “believe in the Lord Jesus Christ and you will be saved!” (Acts 16:31), they don’t footnote that with a fifteen page explanation of the Trinity and the plan of salvation.
That’s really all there is to it. The criminal crucified next to Christ also comes to mind. If we truly needed all of this more complicated doctrine established in our minds in order to be saved, then how would that even work with these passages?
As we’ve mentioned before, one of the best arguments against salvation involving direct propositional knowledge is that it becomes nearly impossible to figure out where to stop without drawing arbitrary lines. For example, consider the blood of Christ:
I dare say, most Christians today do not really even understand what the blood of Christ, the spiritual death of our Lord for all sin, really is or means.
So are we willing to say all these people who are bit fuzzy on the blood of Christ aren’t “really saved”? And this is not some esoteric doctrine either (given that the blood of Christ is what the wine in communion represents)!
In short, including this sort of knowledge in the salvation equation just doesn’t work. Salvation is in fact always dead simple:
What is needed to be saved is the will to be saved on our part by believing and the object of faith in whom we believe, our Savior Jesus Christ: God helping us when we want to be saved through Jesus Christ the One in whom we believe.
Just like salvation is all about faith, so too apostasy
Just like salvation, apostasy is all about faith:
Only unbelievers are not saved (Jn.3:18). For a believer to become unsaved, i.e., apostasy, that requires the complete death of faith (see the link). Failure to grow, failure to pursue sanctification, that is to say, backsliding and sinning, often does lead to a believer reverting to the status of unbeliever. But again that is a very deliberate choice, not a matter of mere knowledge or lack thereof. It’s not about knowledge; it’s about faith.
I suppose we should also note that actually sin is not directly involved either. Sin hardens our hearts to God (which makes it much more likely for us to let go of our faith, it is true), but that is clearly not the same as losing said faith completely. And in like manner, building up the “spiritual knowledge structure” in our hearts with rotten beams and cracked boards will make it much easier for it to all come crumbling down. But a building that lacks structural integrity is also clearly not the same thing as a collapsed building. Obviously we should want to make our “spiritual edifices of truth” sturdy and robust! But the point is that this will only ever be something of a work in progress, even for the very best of us.
Our Lord tells us that tribulation, persecution, and testing are the prime reasons for apostasy (Matt.13:21; Mk.4:17; Lk.8:13); if a person starts to blame God for some disaster or personal loss, turning away from Him is often the result. But confusion over doctrinal points is never the cause of apostasy.
Not having spiritual knowledge learned, believed, and applied (and/or having shoddy workmanship in our faith structure) will make our lives much harder when the wind and waves come and batter us. But at the end of the day, if someone chooses to “faint” during a spiritual test, it won’t be because they misunderstood some point doctrine, but because they willingly elected to turn their back on God and stop trusting in Jesus as their Lord and Savior.
Group discussion: Belief in the existence of Jesus versus trusting Him for salvation; specific knowledge about Christ and the salvation of children
People who merely accept the fact that Jesus existed as a historical person are not saved, for even the demons believe in God (James 2:19). Rather, it is those who choose to put their faith in Jesus—to recognize and trust that He alone is the solution to sin, death, and judgement—who are saved.
God eagerly accepts all who desire to become part of His family through faith in Jesus. The key issue in salvation is the person’s willingness to be saved—or lack thereof; no one will be denied salvation based on a “lack of information”. If specific knowledge were the issue it would be impossible for children to be saved.
Assurance of salvation through spiritual growth
Ichthys: Assurance of salvation through spiritual growth
The following contains discussion of content that was not originally made by me. Please help the original content rank higher in the algorithms by viewing it at its original location, and also giving it a like and a comment and so on (if applicable):
Also, be sure to follow/subscribe to/support the original content creator on all their platforms:
- Website: Ichthys.com
The things labeled "summary points" on this page are highly derivative of the original content, since they are summarizing the original content.
Overview
Source clip from Ichthys
Response #3:
Ichthys is not everyone’s cup of tea. I always advise people not to church-hop because it leads to spiritual indigestion. If two are teaching different things or just in ways that are different and hard to see how they reconcile the net effect is for the believer to not believe either – or to believe the wrong instead of the right. I have seen this many times. Better to find the best tree FOR YOU and stick with it.
As to preaching and teaching not being mutually exclusive, while that may not be absolutely untrue, I have never actually seen traditional preaching and actual teaching of the Bible NOT be mutually exclusive. Since what you are suggesting is, as far as I have ever seen or heard of, a null set, it’s only theoretical. Practically speaking, a church is either genuinely committed to teaching the truth in depth or it is not; where it is, sermonizing is absent; where it is not, that single motivational talk on Sunday morning is what passes for “teaching”. Case in point: your attendance on them has not brought you peace . . . which comes with growth.
As to the charge that I was hesitant to answer your questions “head on”: I answer questions the way I am led by the Spirit to answer them – not that I don’t take full responsibility for what I say (anyone can be wrong about His guidance occasionally). The point is, the right answer to a question is not always to answer the question the way the person has phrased it. The right answer, it seems to me, is to give the person the answer they need, even if it is not the answer they want. This is what I always try to do (you can find plenty of examples of that in the gospels). I also always try not to say things that are not biblical or biblically based. Whenever traditional theology comes up, it is virtually impossible to give straight answers directly to these questions because the questions themselves, being theological (i.e., not biblical), usually have inherent in them many non-biblical assumptions so that a direct answer would necessarily involve itself in the same theological fallacies upon which the question is based. So I try to stick with the truth, even if that may seem to some “hesitant and indirect”.
As to “sound ministries such as yours” teaching that unless you fully understand and believe the right things about Christ you can’t be/are not saved: I hope you’re not saying that this is what Ichthys is saying but only that Ichthys is a “sound ministry” – because this is not what I say (as the previous emails have, I hope, made clear). If so, I have to add that the other “sound ministries” you are referring to here are wrong on this point – so that I would question their “soundness”. If that is not what you are saying, please reread the previous responses I gave you about what is necessary to be saved. I was very clear (or so I thought), about the fact that not very much knowledge is needed to be saved in the first place. Honestly, you can’t really tell me that you had come up with an “Arian conception of Christ” before you were saved? More likely: you believed and began reading and started to wonder about this or that aspect of the truth. That is typical. The only way to avoid dangerous speculation is to be committed to a good teaching ministry from the start – but few of us fell into that right away. Usually we needed to have it made clear to us that we needed spiritual growth first – and that often only comes through “the school of hard knocks”.
As to the sentiment “if you don’t believe that Jesus is fully God and fully man, you cant be/are not saved” being “all over the place on Ichthys as well” – Cite me one place where I said that please. Of course, Jesus IS fully God and a genuine human being. But if I were giving an unbeliever the gospel, I wouldn’t turn it into a theology lesson, even a correct one. I would explain that he/she could have eternal life simply by putting their faith, their trust, their belief in Jesus Christ. The Spirit uses that kernel of the truth to save all who are willing. The beautiful details and deeper truths come after one is saved. It’s never backwards.
As to your questions, again, I’ve answered them as I’ve answered them and am not going to be pinned down to the constructs the questions contain when I disagree with those and see them as faulty.
What I’ve said: 1) this is about faith, not knowledge; 2) the Spirit knows who is ready to accept Christ and gives that person enough knowledge to do so, empowering the understanding of the “mustard seed” worth of truth; 3) no one has “full knowledge” of these issues when they are saved; 4) if someone later decides to deny the truth about Christ or any other truth it is not good; 5) but the seed of “faith in Christ” remains for all believers (1Jn.3:9), that is, those who believe. If their knowledge if faulty, they need to get that straightened out. If they don’t, they make themselves vulnerable; if they stop believing entirely, they are no longer believers (that is apostasy; see the link). Where individual believers are on this spectrum is something that is not possible for us to parse from the outside; and as your example demonstrates, it is also not possible often for the individual in question to do so with perfect confidence even for him/herself. What all such need is spiritual growth: find a source of truth . . . and start believing it. That is where confidence comes from, and peace and joy as well.
And because you are sons, God has sent forth the Spirit of His Son into your hearts, crying out, “Abba, Father!”
You are a believer. You know that because the Spirit tells you that – constantly. Arguing with Him about this is not profitable. My best advice: let go of this “bone”, set it aside, accept that you belong to Jesus, accept that this is true even if you struggled with some points of truth about Him in the past, accept the truth now, and move on with a broad front approach to spiritual growth, not limiting yourself to this one issue: no matter how much you learn about this one issue, no one issue is capable of producing the growth that will bring you peace.
Peace I leave with you, My peace I give to you; not as the world gives do I give to you. Let not your heart be troubled, neither let it be afraid.
In Jesus,
Bob L.
Summary points
The solution to salvation hand-wringing is spiritual growth. How to do it correctly?
Consider these quotes from this section of the conversation:
Ichthys is not everyone’s cup of tea. I always advise people not to church-hop because it leads to spiritual indigestion. If two are teaching different things or just in ways that are different and hard to see how they reconcile the net effect is for the believer to not believe either – or to believe the wrong instead of the right. I have seen this many times. Better to find the best tree FOR YOU and stick with it.
As to preaching and teaching not being mutually exclusive, while that may not be absolutely untrue, I have never actually seen traditional preaching and actual teaching of the Bible NOT be mutually exclusive. Since what you are suggesting is, as far as I have ever seen or heard of, a null set, it’s only theoretical. Practically speaking, a church is either genuinely committed to teaching the truth in depth or it is not; where it is, sermonizing is absent; where it is not, that single motivational talk on Sunday morning is what passes for “teaching”. Case in point: your attendance on them has not brought you peace . . . which comes with growth.
We argued in the last lesson that there is only one proper path: seeking doctrinally accurate truth, and then actually believing it. If someone feels they lack conviction about their salvation and would like to develop more ironclad assurance, then this should be the answer.
However, one will very quickly realize that there are some practical hurdles that arise once you actually start trying to do this:
- You have to find ministries actually teaching the truth in-depth
- You have to be willing to give those ministries your trust, so that you actually believe what they teach
We will examine these two matters separately.
First, regarding finding ministries actually teaching the truth in-depth, Dr. Luginbill’s comments about “sermonizing” are most applicable in the context of our current place and time. Especially nowadays, not everything called Bible teaching is actually Bible teaching proper. How do we know? Well, you can simply observe what goes on, and ask yourself a few basic questions:
- How many scripture quotations are there per minute?
- What percentage of the teaching time is spent actually exegeting the text of the Bible (as opposed to telling stories, using fanciful illustrations, pulling in pop-psychology, engaging in empty motivation speaking, and so on)?
- For any scripture that is in fact discussed, how many points are brought up that are not self-evident from the passages themselves (i.e., things that go beyond what most lay Christians reading their own Bibles could understand even without needing anyone to explain it to them)?
One needn’t even set the expectations extremely high here before you realize that most of what gets called Bible teaching flunks these basic questions spectacularly. This is a serious problem for those who wish to grow spiritually in order to have firmer assurance of their salvation, because it is impossible to grow big spiritual muscles (the sort that let you find victory in wrestling with various common doubts) when you are being starved for proper spiritual nourishment.
So this is one serious barrier to spiritual maturity (and therefore assurance of salvation) that people in our modern day face.
The other big issue is that of actually believing the in-depth teaching being taken in. To be perfectly honest, given the lack of substance in what is taught at most places, I certainly understand why many lay Christians have “trust issues” when it comes to accepting the spiritual leadership of most modern pastor-teachers. I wouldn’t much trust such “teachers” either.
However, it is nonetheless true that most people in the body of Christ do not themselves have the requisite spiritual grifts and detailed preparation that are necessary in order to properly “mine” complex truth from the Bible on their own. Do not misunderstand—in this, we are not saying that only pastor-teachers are qualified to read and understand their Bibles. No indeed, all believers should be diligently reading their Bibles, and then checking what their teachers say against it (cf. Acts 17:11). It is impossible to test teachers against the Bible (i.e., identify “good fruit” from “bad fruit”, in the sense of Matthew 7:15-20) if you don’t know what is in the Bible to begin with, right?
But past a certain point, lay Christians will need to accept the authority of some pastor-teacher, and learn under them. In order grow past a certain point, this step is most certainly required.
What that means in the specifics is that at some point all lay Christians will have to swallow their pride and put themselves under the teaching authority of a gifted and prepared Bible teacher. It is no shameful thing to inherently struggle with this a bit. After all, the natural inclination of humanity is pride, not humility (and that holds for every single one of us, down to a person). People do not much like submitting themselves to government authority either, and the clear biblical teachings that parents have authority over their children and husbands over their wives are also similarly rather unpopular teachings on the whole. However, God has set up these authority relationships in the world for a reason, and we need to be pleased to trust Him and His plan.
Once we get over our aversion to trusting somebody else to begin with, rather than only ourselves (which is perhaps more than half the battle), we then have to deal with the question of whether to try and trust more than one external person at a time, or more or less only one at a time. The answer, in short, is that we should mostly only stick with one Bible teacher at time.
The reason for this is because trying to trust more than one at a time will inherently lead to problems when their teachings contradict each other, as they are almost certain to eventually. In such situations when Bible teachers disagree, it is tempting for lay Christians to end up believing neither teacher in practice. But knowledge not mixed with faith does us no good, remember? So even understanding that no Bible teachers are perfect and they too will get things wrong occasionally, it is more dangerous overall for us to hold back believing our teachers because some other teachers occasionally disagree with them. If we start down that path, we will quickly find ourselves in the situation of knowing much but actually believing little, and then where will we be when it comes to epignosis?
Now, clearly having this level of trust in a Bible teacher is no small thing! You must find someone truly worthy of such deep trust, and continually check their teaching and conduct against the Bible, to make sure they hold up even when put under microscope. In short, you should be choosy about the shepherd of your soul (so to speak). You wouldn’t trust just anyone to treat you medically, right? So why would trust just anyone to treat you spiritually?
But once you find a “good tree, that bears good fruit”, you need to be pleased to park yourself under it and continually eat, such that you grow big and strong spiritually.
Only then, at that point, will you “no longer be infants, tossed back and forth by the waves, and blown here and there by every wind of teaching and by the cunning and craftiness of people in their deceitful scheming” (Ephesians 4:14, NIV11), but instead “be able to test and approve what God’s will is—his good, pleasing and perfect will” (Romans 12:2b, NIV11).
And, to our present topic, you will be able to find victory when you wrestle with assurance of salvation, and other such worries and doubts. Your new spiritual muscles will see to that.
More on the concept of “asking the right questions”, and refusing to constrain salvation to constructs of “theology” and “logic”
Consider these quotes from this section of the conversation:
As to the charge that I was hesitant to answer your questions “head on”: I answer questions the way I am led by the Spirit to answer them – not that I don’t take full responsibility for what I say (anyone can be wrong about His guidance occasionally). The point is, the right answer to a question is not always to answer the question the way the person has phrased it. The right answer, it seems to me, is to give the person the answer they need, even if it is not the answer they want. This is what I always try to do (you can find plenty of examples of that in the gospels). I also always try not to say things that are not biblical or biblically based. Whenever traditional theology comes up, it is virtually impossible to give straight answers directly to these questions because the questions themselves, being theological (i.e., not biblical), usually have inherent in them many non-biblical assumptions so that a direct answer would necessarily involve itself in the same theological fallacies upon which the question is based. So I try to stick with the truth, even if that may seem to some “hesitant and indirect”.
As to your questions, again, I’ve answered them as I’ve answered them and am not going to be pinned down to the constructs the questions contain when I disagree with those and see them as faulty.
Bible teachers who try to be thoughtful in what they answer and how they answer (entirely in the spiritual best interests of those they are talking to, to be clear) may often get flak for not addressing things in the way their correspondents wish—both in terms of failing to directly answer things asked, or in terms of always changing the subject to different topics.
This is especially the case when interacting with formal academic disciplines that operate according to certain sets of rules that may or may not be entirely biblical. In the eyes of the professional academics, if you fail to do things according to their rules or their methodology, your conclusions must inherently be suspect.
Yet it is very important for Bible teachers put their foot down and only ever talk about the Bible on its own terms, rather than allowing others to set definitions or axioms that make it inherent impossible to actually present the truth in a biblical way.
Consider 1 Corinthians 1:18:
For the word of the cross is folly to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God.
Rather than trying to make the word of the cross seem less foolish in order to please the academic-discourse-police, we should instead stand unashamed of the “otherworldiness” of the gospel, for lack of a better term. Compare Romans 1:16:
For I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is the power of God that brings salvation to everyone who believes: first to the Jew, then to the Gentile.
It should not bother us if other people think we are backwards and ignorant and simplistic fools for putting childlike trust in God and His Word, and doing away with all these complicated extra-biblical constructs. We interpret scripture with scripture; words mean what they mean in the Bible based on how they are used in the Bible. Can we use logic to reason about biblical principles, and build some common-sense guidelines to help inform our interpretation and exegesis? Sure. Based on what the Bible actually says.
So are we anti-theology and anti-logic? Not in the way some parties accuse us of being. We are anti-extra-biblical definitions of terms and conceptual framing, and not terribly shy about painting with broad strokes and saying “most” of what gets labeled as “theology” and “logic” uses extra-biblical definitions of terms and conceptual framing.
To pull as back to our subject, this current topic of “what do I have to know in order to be saved?” is an excellent example of why all of this important. The Bible doesn’t talk about knowing things in order to be saved, but in terms of believing in Jesus Christ in order to be saved. If the writers of the New Testament (writing under the influence of the Holy Spirit) meant “know” rather than “believe”, then they would have used a different verb in the Greek… but they didn’t.
Therefore, we shouldn’t ever actually engage with questions about what you need to know in order to be saved. We should instead instantly switch the subject to belief. That is the only way we can be faithful workmen of God’s Word, “cutting straight the word of truth” (2 Timothy 2:15).
And in the same way, any time questions or discussions head in a direction that is similarly extra-biblical (or even fully un-biblical, as here), we should not be shy in immediately changing the subject back to vocabulary and concepts that the Bible really does teach, and putting the emphasis firmly there, and only there.
I will close in saying that one of the most common forms that this principle tends to take in practice is in Bible teachers prescribing spiritual growth as the solution to all life’s problems. I really do understand why people can view it as something of red herring (especially if what is being asked is something very detailed and specific), but buckling down to focus on spiritual growth is often the answer that people truly need to hear. And so we should say it, and put the focus there. Even if it means we “don’t answer questions” or “refuse to do ‘proper’ theology and logic”.
“If I were giving an unbeliever the gospel, I wouldn’t turn it into a theology lesson, even a correct one”
Consider this quote from this section of the conversation:
As to “sound ministries such as yours” teaching that unless you fully understand and believe the right things about Christ you can’t be/are not saved: I hope you’re not saying that this is what Ichthys is saying but only that Ichthys is a “sound ministry” – because this is not what I say (as the previous emails have, I hope, made clear). If so, I have to add that the other “sound ministries” you are referring to here are wrong on this point – so that I would question their “soundness”. If that is not what you are saying, please reread the previous responses I gave you about what is necessary to be saved. I was very clear (or so I thought), about the fact that not very much knowledge is needed to be saved in the first place. Honestly, you can’t really tell me that you had come up with an “Arian conception of Christ” before you were saved? More likely: you believed and began reading and started to wonder about this or that aspect of the truth. That is typical. The only way to avoid dangerous speculation is to be committed to a good teaching ministry from the start – but few of us fell into that right away. Usually we needed to have it made clear to us that we needed spiritual growth first – and that often only comes through “the school of hard knocks”.
As to the sentiment “if you don’t believe that Jesus is fully God and fully man, you cant be/are not saved” being “all over the place on Ichthys as well” – Cite me one place where I said that please. Of course, Jesus IS fully God and a genuine human being. But if I were giving an unbeliever the gospel, I wouldn’t turn it into a theology lesson, even a correct one. I would explain that he/she could have eternal life simply by putting their faith, their trust, their belief in Jesus Christ. The Spirit uses that kernel of the truth to save all who are willing. The beautiful details and deeper truths come after one is saved. It’s never backwards.
Some specific sentences that jump out:
- As to “sound ministries such as yours” teaching that unless you fully understand and believe the right things about Christ you can’t be/are not saved: I hope you’re not saying that this is what Ichthys is saying but only that Ichthys is a “sound ministry” – because this is not what I say.
- I was very clear (or so I thought), about the fact that not very much knowledge is needed to be saved in the first place.
- As to the sentiment “if you don’t believe that Jesus is fully God and fully man, you cant be/are not saved” being “all over the place on Ichthys as well” – Cite me one place where I said that please.
If you want proof texts for the fact that Ichthys as a ministry does not teach that specific knowledge is required for salvation, well here you go. You can’t get much clearer than this.
What are the consequences of this in terms of our approach to evangelism, then?
[I]f I were giving an unbeliever the gospel, I wouldn’t turn it into a theology lesson, even a correct one. I would explain that he/she could have eternal life simply by putting their faith, their trust, their belief in Jesus Christ. The Spirit uses that kernel of the truth to save all who are willing. The beautiful details and deeper truths come after one is saved. It’s never backwards.
Because salvation is about faith not knowledge, we should not put the cart before the horse and complicate our gospel pitch by pulling in “matters of knowledge”. Is it important that Jesus was both fully God and fully man? Of course. Should we seek to completely understand and appreciate the mechanics of how what He did on the cross frees us from sin and death? Undoubtedly. But these things (and others like them) come after someone has already chosen to trust in Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior. Trying to make them part of that initial step of faith just gets everything muddled.
Trusting in Jesus as one’s personal Lord and Savior does not necessarily mean believing in all the correct teachings concerning Him
Consider this quote from this section of the conversation:
What I’ve said: 1) this is about faith, not knowledge; 2) the Spirit knows who is ready to accept Christ and gives that person enough knowledge to do so, empowering the understanding of the “mustard seed” worth of truth; 3) no one has “full knowledge” of these issues when they are saved; 4) if someone later decides to deny the truth about Christ or any other truth it is not good; 5) but the seed of “faith in Christ” remains for all believers (1Jn.3:9), that is, those who believe. If their knowledge if faulty, they need to get that straightened out. If they don’t, they make themselves vulnerable; if they stop believing entirely, they are no longer believers (that is apostasy; see the link). Where individual believers are on this spectrum is something that is not possible for us to parse from the outside; and as your example demonstrates, it is also not possible often for the individual in question to do so with perfect confidence even for him/herself. What all such need is spiritual growth: find a source of truth . . . and start believing it. That is where confidence comes from, and peace and joy as well.
Boy, people do not like this teaching. We are right back to the same sort of legalistic judginess that others commonly adopt when saying “people that believe homosexuality/transgenderism/abortion/etc. are not sinful cannot be saved”, except now it has turned into “people that have some pretty sketchy beliefs concerning Christology/Soteriology/etc. cannot be saved”.
In either case, the point isn’t that wrong beliefs aren’t a problem, or extremely dangerous spiritually. The point is that they are not themselves part of “belief in Jesus Christ as one’s personal Lord and Savior”. People certainly try to assert that they are so, but based on what? Their opinion?
As we have said before, it is positively scandalous that the bar for salvation is as low as it truly is. God’s grace is scandalous. Getting saved is so easy you can have a pretty messed up understanding of the truth (or live in a terrible mess of sin), and still be saved.
We should obviously not aspire to such a low state. But we’d best take care that we don’t forget that Jesus came for the sick, not the healthy (cf. Matthew 9:12; Mark 2:17; Luke 5:31). Otherwise we will find God reasoning with us in the same manner as the Father reasoned with the older brother in the parable of the prodigal son:
25 “Meanwhile, the older son was in the field. When he came near the house, he heard music and dancing. 26 So he called one of the servants and asked him what was going on. 27 ‘Your brother has come,’ he replied, ‘and your father has killed the fattened calf because he has him back safe and sound.’
28 “The older brother became angry and refused to go in. So his father went out and pleaded with him. 29 But he answered his father, ‘Look! All these years I’ve been slaving for you and never disobeyed your orders. Yet you never gave me even a young goat so I could celebrate with my friends. 30 But when this son of yours who has squandered your property with prostitutes comes home, you kill the fattened calf for him!’
31 “‘My son,’ the father said, ‘you are always with me, and everything I have is yours. 32 But we had to celebrate and be glad, because this brother of yours was dead and is alive again; he was lost and is found.’”